Ethics and Democracy

About 

An Op-ed in Arabic written by Omar Abdulaziz Hallaj for the Syrian periodical “Baladouna” (no longer in circulation). 

This Op-ed is a pre-LUGARIT work by our expert.

Summary

The Op-ed by Omar Abdulaziz Hallaj delves into the intricate relationship between ethics and democracy, particularly in the context of the Arab world. Mr. Hallaj begins by addressing the skepticism and challenges of implementing democracy in this region, emphasizing that democracy requires a foundation of moral values to thrive.


Mr. Hallaj critically examines the notion of democracy being reduced to mere majority rule, using historical examples like Nazi Germany to illustrate how democracies can be subverted when ethical principles are ignored. This leads to the argument that for democracy to succeed, a moral base among citizens is crucial. The article asserts that such a base would prevent the exploitation of democratic institutions for immoral ends.


The discussion then shifts to morality in Arab culture, highlighting its evolution and its link to public morals and religious teachings. Mr. Hallaj points out the fluidity of moral standards and their dependence on societal changes. He critiques the superficial understanding of morality often promoted by religious institutions, arguing that this approach can lead to injustice.


Mr. Hallaj emphasizes the need for a critical reevaluation of moral values to support democratic transformations in the Arab world. He argues that simply advocating for justice and freedom is insufficient; instead, there needs to be a clear understanding of these concepts, respecting the rights of all societal groups, including minorities.


The op-ed further explores the idea of freedom as a fundamental democratic principle, stressing the importance of balancing individual and societal freedoms. Mr. Hallaj criticizes the suppression of individual freedoms in the Arab world under various pretexts and calls for a reassessment of the role of religion in defining freedom.


Citizenship is proposed as an alternative concept to coexistence and tolerance, emphasizing rights and responsibilities. Mr. Hallaj argues that true citizenship involves not just claiming rights but also fulfilling duties towards society and defending the rights of others.


The conclusion emphasizes the individual's moral responsibility in supporting democracy. Hallaj underscores the need for active participation in democratic processes and institutions and warns against the dangers of majoritarianism and the marginalization of minority voices.


Overall, the op-ed provides a profound analysis of the ethical foundations necessary for a robust and just democracy, particularly highlighting the challenges and opportunities in the Arab world. It advocates for a deep, critical engagement with moral values as a prerequisite for the successful implementation and sustenance of democratic systems.

Header Photo

Mithras Statue in Ostia Antica, near Rome, Italy.  2017.  Photo © Ore HDR - Via ShutterStock.   Link >